Welcome to Malatesta Pizza and Cheesesteaks
Newtown Square’s go-to spot for pizza and cheesesteaks! 🍕🥪
Welcome to Malatesta Pizza and Cheesesteaks in Newtown Square, PA! We’re a family-owned restaurant serving high-quality pizzas and cheesesteaks with traditional Italian roots and a modern neighborhood feel. Our team focuses on careful prep, thorough cleaning, and fast service. Grab a classic pie, a specialty pie, a hearty cheesesteak, or a quick meal for the whole crew available for takeout and delivery.
Square, Round, and Always Fresh
At Malatesta Pizza and Cheesesteaks, the menu keeps it simple and satisfying. Try our Square pies, Round pies, or one of our specialty pies. We also serve classic pizzas, square grandma-style pies, thin-crust bar pies, and made-to-order cheesesteaks. Every item is prepared with care and baked or cooked fresh for your order.
Fast Pickup, Easy Online Ordering
Ordering from Malatesta Pizza and Cheesesteaks is quick and simple. Place your pizza or cheesesteak order online, and get it ready for takeout or delivered straight to your door. We focus on quality, speed, and a smooth experience, so you can enjoy fresh, hot meals any day we’re open.
See the Pies up Close
Take a look at our Red Squares, Red Rounds, and tomato pie favorites—fresh, bold, and ready for takeout.
Simple. Fresh. Legendary.
Meet our World Famous Tomato Pie, the pizza locals come back for again and again. Topped with house-made tomato sauce and a light touch of pecorino romano, it’s a clean, classic bite no extras needed. Don’t forget our signature cheesesteaks, made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection, for a true taste of Newtown Square.
Address: 3525 West Chester Pike, Newtown Square, PA 19073
Type: Takeout-only pizza restaurant
Ordering: Takeout and Delivery
Hours:
Mon: Closed
Tue: Closed
Wed: 11am–9pm
Thu: 11am–9pm
Fri: 11am–9pm
Sat: 11am–9pm
Sun: 11am–5pm
Note: Closed Mondays & Tuesdays for prep and deep cleaning. ✅
What our guests are saying
My family and I REALLY enjoyed this pizza! (One pie was plenty for 3 people.) We ordered the Pepperoni Pie and it was delicious! The sauce was slightly sweet, and the crust was perfectly cooked. The cheese combination was spot on too! Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a good pizza in the NS area! We will definitely be ordering from here again soon!
Halee K.
A ten minute pickup time for pizza is nonexistent. Not here! Malatesta's ovens must be firing on all cylinders! The bar pizza was simply elegance in my mouth. A beautiful, crunchy, crispy, slightly chewy undercarriage with tasty sauce and cheese. The pecorino romano on top was the icing on the cake. The white rosemary potato pie was just as good and especially different. The customer service was friendly and welcoming. This shop is take-out only with an option for delivery. Do not sleep on Malatesta's! It is a dream!
Thomas H.
Love the pizza, love the vibe! We’ve gone several times now and tried a different pie each time, and they are all great. And everyone works there is really nice. Our new favorite pizza shoppe! 🍕
Monica S.
Malatesta’s Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Chicken Cheesesteak, Vegetarian Food, Cheesesteak, and White Pizza
Where are you located?
We are located in Newtown Square, PA at 3525 West Chester Pike
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Newtown Square, Saint Albans, Newtown, Larchmont, Larchmont Square, Newtown Heights, Marple, Florida Park, Wyola, Echo Valley, Aronwold, Foxcroft, Broomall, Castle Rock, Radnor, Brookthorpe Hills, Waterloo Mills, Sycamore Mills, Radnor Township, Ithan.
Anything else?
We are also known for Family Friendly Restaurant
Our location
